I saw “Star Wars: The Force Awakens.” Now, I didn’t hate it. But I can’t say that I loved it. It was good. Not as good as the originals
but better than the prequels. There were
cool things (the special effects were great eye candy, the pacing was fast and
intense, and it was cool to see Han and Chewy being Han and Chewy). But, of course, I have to ruin everything by
blabbing my stupid opinions because I’m a nerd and I need some sort of narcissistic
release. So I’ll just go ahead and get the
big spoilers out of the way. Captain
Kirk dies, Data gets emotions, and they completely destroy the Enterprise. Anywhooooo….
Understand this: I
take Star Wars VERY seriously. It was my
entire childhood, so I put it up on a big ATAT-sized pedestal. So I was excited to hear that Lawrence Kasdan
was writing. After all, he did write “Empire
Strikes Back” and “Return of the Jedi,” two of the most monumental and influential
movies in film history. However, he also
wrote and directed “Dreamcatcher.”
That’s that movie about aliens that burst out of people’s butts. And I’m not using hyperbole or being
sarcastic. They pop out of your
pooper. Just watch it. NO, DON'T! Just take my word for it. It’s
terrible.
TFA was not a poop monster. Thank God. But I still question some of Kasdan’s
decisions. Today, I had a friend ask, "Well, how would you have written it?" I'll tell ya!
RHYME AND REASON
Initially, it was stated that this film was to “rhyme” with
the original film. But as nearly
everyone has pointed out, it doesn’t quite rhyme. It’s more like a rap song that sampled a
cover band. It’s too similar, and for
me, it weakens its impact.
James Cameron’s “Aliens” is a perfect example of how to make
a sequel that rhymes but feels like a totally different film. At the end of “Aliens,” Ripley reaches
safety but risks her own life by going back into a crumbling complex on the verge of exploding to save Newt. Of course
she’s going to do that! Newt was a cute blond girl with an English
accent. But she did the EXACT SAME THING in the first film! The Nostromo was set to explode, Ripley was
safely onboard the escape shuttle. But
she went back onto the crumbling Nostromo.
Why? To save a Jonesy, a cute
blond kitty with an English accent!
Meow, indeed. |
"Alien" suit in Airlock Scene |
In “Aliens,” Ripley rescues Newt and gets back on board the
Sulaco to safety. Whew! That was a close one. But the Momma Alien snuck onboard the Sulaco,
too! Guess what! In the original film, Ripley gets back to
the shuttle, thinks she is safe only to discover that the alien snuck onboard
the shuttle, too! So what does Ripley
do? In both films, she dons a safety
suit, and blows them out of the airlock.
"Aliens" suit in Airlock Scene |
She also calls the Mother Alien a “bitch.” You know what other non-human she called a
bitch? The Nostromo’s computer, MOTHER, when
she couldn’t stop the self-destruct sequence.
And in both instances, it was used a tension-breaker. There are many, many other callbacks. It can be argued that they are both essentially the same film, but I have
NEVER heard anyone ever complain about it.
Why? They just felt like a
different films. Cameron took those
similarities, but he carved out a completely different approach and atmosphere.
“The Force Awakes” was too blatant and obvious with its
inspirations. It was essentially “A New
Hope” dressed in the Emperor’s new clothes.
And I’d imagine his robes would probably smell like sauerkraut and
mothballs.
STARKILLER BASE
The bad guys really need to get out of the
Blowing-Up-Planets business. They
aren’t particularly good at it. They
need a new tactic. Or at least they need
to hire someone else to design their exhaust ports. The assault on Starkiller Base really felt
like a video game. I’ve seen this
before, and honestly they did it better the first time. And who cared about the planets they did blow
up? We don’t even know anything about
them.
This film should have started out on Tatooine. We see a sandy-blond young man emerging
after a hard day’s work on the moisture farm.
He looks into horizon and sees this breath-taking double sunset. The music swells dramatically as he thinks
about his hopes, his dreams, his past, and his future. But just as he looks back up to the two
suns…one of the suns begins to flicker and then dies out. Then a red blast from the outer regions of
space decimates his planet. As the
planet is ripped apart, we hear millions of voices cry out in terror…and then
they are suddenly silenced. Cut to
somewhere in a remote, uncharted region of space, we see Luke Skywalker all alone. He suddenly is hit with a great disturbance
in the force and experiences the pain of their deaths. And he knows that their blood is on his
hands. He knows Kylo Ren chose his home
planet in an effort to smoke him out of hiding and exact his revenge.
There, we showed something familiar…something we have a
connection to…something the characters are connected to…something we all cared
about…
and we turned it upside down and took it in a direction that
no one would dare to.
REMNANTS OF THE EMPIRE
At the end of ROTJ, both of the Empire's big wigs died. Coruscant celebrated the end of the Empire's rule by toppling the statue of Palpatine. And fireworks lit up the Endor sky as Ewoks danced like little idiots singing, "Yub yub." The Empire was left in shambles, a New Republic was formed, and balance was restored to the Force. But was it really?
Star Wars canon now dictates that the First Order rose from remnants of the Empire. But what bothers me is that the First Order seems MORE powerful than the Empire, as if it was the events of Episodes 4 thru 6 had no impact. Geez Louise, they can destroy multiple planets AND suck the energy from a sun! To me, this completely trivializes the battles of Yavin and Endor and I think it was a lazy and expected direction.
It would have been WAY more interesting to have the First Order operating as a independent terrorist organization trying to undermine the New Republic...you know, kinda like what the Rebels did to the Empire (there's yer rhyming, JJ!). That would give a little more validity to how a young outsider like Ben Solo could work his way up ranks so quickly. The First Order could have been on the downlow for 30 years, slowly plotting their own "Battle of Yavin" moment on the New Republic as the entire galaxy has completely forgotten what life was like under the rule of the Empire. With their attack, it would catch everyone off guard and set the course for real conflict in the next installments. I think this was another missed opportunity.
REMNANTS OF THE EMPIRE
At the end of ROTJ, both of the Empire's big wigs died. Coruscant celebrated the end of the Empire's rule by toppling the statue of Palpatine. And fireworks lit up the Endor sky as Ewoks danced like little idiots singing, "Yub yub." The Empire was left in shambles, a New Republic was formed, and balance was restored to the Force. But was it really?
Star Wars canon now dictates that the First Order rose from remnants of the Empire. But what bothers me is that the First Order seems MORE powerful than the Empire, as if it was the events of Episodes 4 thru 6 had no impact. Geez Louise, they can destroy multiple planets AND suck the energy from a sun! To me, this completely trivializes the battles of Yavin and Endor and I think it was a lazy and expected direction.
It would have been WAY more interesting to have the First Order operating as a independent terrorist organization trying to undermine the New Republic...you know, kinda like what the Rebels did to the Empire (there's yer rhyming, JJ!). That would give a little more validity to how a young outsider like Ben Solo could work his way up ranks so quickly. The First Order could have been on the downlow for 30 years, slowly plotting their own "Battle of Yavin" moment on the New Republic as the entire galaxy has completely forgotten what life was like under the rule of the Empire. With their attack, it would catch everyone off guard and set the course for real conflict in the next installments. I think this was another missed opportunity.
THE CHARACTERS
Looking pretty intense...moments before she gets punched and shoved into a trash compactor. |
CAPTAIN PHASMA: What
exactly is she captain of? Starkiller
Base is on a planet, not a ship. It was
just confusing. Now, don’t get me
wrong, some of my all-time favorite “captains” actually lack credentials
(particularly Cap’n Crunch and Captain Kangaroo). But her title left me
expecting…well…something more. I am also
disappointed that her character looked so cool, but she had about as much
authority as an assistant manager at a 99 Cent Store. We needed to see her actually do
something…ANYTHING…to make her intimidating.
She just kinda discounts Finn’s panic attack and that’s it. And ironically, I’ve found more impressive
discounts at the 99 Cent Store.
FINN: Finn’s first
day on the job doesn’t go too well. After
witnessing a fellow trooper die, and he starts rethinking his career
options. I’m confused by this choice. It seems like this was a perfect opportunity
to see him show sympathy for the people in peril to reconnect with his
suppressed humanity. He seemed to be more
disturbed by the death of a person committing the executions, not the actual
people being executed. Of course, they
are all humans…but with Storm Trooper gear on, those soldiers appear to lose
their humanity. I thought that was the
point of those armored outfits (since they definitely don’t protect anyone from
laser blasts). Plus, they were all
supposed to be mentally reprogrammed from childhood so he shouldn’t have emotionally
connected with any fellow soldiers. It really
felt like he was mourning the death of a mindless drone.
Why not have him experience a PTSD panic attack as he is
about to kill the colonists, flashing him back to his childhood when he was
taken from his family? This could give
him and Rey mirror opposite backstories (he’s taken from his family, she is
abandoned by hers) and make them somewhat of kindred spirits. Then Captain Phasma could confront him,
demand that he kills as ordered. When he
refuses, she angrily relieves him of his post, kills the colonists without mercy
or hesitation, and tells him to get back on the shuttle to await further mental
reprogramming. This would make Phasma dangerous
and unpredictable, and make the scene feel less forced. HA forced tee hee.
KYLO REN: I’m not
sure what was going on with Adam Driver.
I know he’s a good actor…but when he takes the mask off he’s kinda
unbelievable. And now, I shouldn’t be
criticizing anyone’s appearance (I mean, I look like a diseased yak with a bad
perm). But Driver is odd-looking. People in my theatre actually laughed when
they saw his face. They could have
scarred up his face or something. He
needed to be intense and scary. It
didn’t help that his character was whiny.
And when he got shot by Chewbacca…why did he bleed? Wouldn’t a laser blast instantly cauterize the
wound? I am also not sure of why he is
such a fanboy of his grandpappy. In the
end, Vader became good and tried to redeem himself. What legacy is he trying to complete on
Vader’s behalf? And why hasn’t Ghost
Vader come to him and said, “Hey, Drakar Noir!
Stop being a poopy head!”
REY: I assume that
Rey was a Padawan before she was dropped off at Jakku after Kylo Ren began
executing the remaining Jedi, and had her memory suppressed by some Jedi mind
trick. That could be the only
explanation as to why she is able to access the force so quickly when it took
Luke 3 films to master it. However, the
first object she was able to move was a lightsaber in the snow…And that is the exact
same object that Luke was first able to move with the force (in the Wampa’s
cave). That was a nice touch. She’s probably a relative of Luke or a former
student of his. I’m sure it’ll be
revealed in the upcoming installments.
This is the Chewy I wanted to see. |
CHEWBACCA: Han and
Chewy were awesome, the best part of the film for me. But when Chewy's 4
decade-long bromance comes to end with Han's death, he just kinda roars and starts shooting lasers. Shouldn’t Chewy become the brutal animal that
he was meant to be? We could have seen
a side of him that we have only heard about… contorting his face in an
uncontrollable, animalistic rage….ripping storm troopers limbs apart as if he
was playing Dejarik against a cheating droid.
It would have been amazing. SIDE NOTE: My friend, Vince, made a great suggestion regarding Han and Chewy...while they are doing their silly bickering back and forth, it would have been awesome to have Han say something to Chewy like, "I did too shoot first!" I think he's right, and people would have cheered in the audience.
MAZ: Am I the only
one that thinks she looks like a bald Edna Mode from The Incredibles? Her character was kinda forgettable. Which is a shame because it seems like a lot
of work went into bringing her to life.
I suspect maybe she was cool and complicated, but her role was seriously
edited for time.
BB8: So cute. But I like Chopper from Star Wars Rebels
better. BTW, if you aren’t watching Star
Wars Rebels on Disney XD, you are missing out.
It is very Star-Wars-ish with LOTS of influence from Ralph McQuarrie’s
work.
LIGHT SABER DUELS
Sigh. The prequels have all of
the light saber battles beat, I hate to admit.
INTERNET CHATTER
There
was a rumor that the film was supposed to start with Luke’s severed hand still
holding his Light Saber floating through space and finding its way to
Jakku. WHAT? HOW?
Luke’s hand was severed on Bespin, not in space. And even if it did end up in space, wouldn’t
it just burn up upon entry of Jakku’s atmosphere? Hopefully, this was just a rumor. If it was included, I would have just sat
there with a big ole sourpuss expression and crossed arms saying, “Well now,
this just will NOT do. Not do at all!”
So that’s my problems with the film. Now, understand that I still enjoyed it, but
I had issues with the writing. Mainly
because I am a control freak and I spent countless hours playing with my Star
Wars action figures as a child (long after my friends had graduated to He-man
and G.I. Joe). There are a lot of cool
bits, but Kasdan let me down. But hey,
the next film is going to be directed by Rian Johnson. And he’s awesome. He directed the Ozymandias episode of “Breaking
Bad,” which for me was probably the best hour of television I had ever
witnessed. I think that he is going to
bring a lot to the franchise, and I can’t wait.
I just hope he questions some of Kasdan’s poop alien moments. We can’t let another turd get through the
blockade.